Showing posts with label Thinking about the 1940s woman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thinking about the 1940s woman. Show all posts

Monday, March 10, 2014

"Things were better in my day!" Or were they?

So many people talk about the past like it was perfect. The days were longer, the weather better, children more polite and adults had more morals. Children did more and complained less. Life was simple, and there weren't pedophiles loitering around every corner. Not like now, they say, usually muttering an excessive number of 'tut tuts". Listening to some of these people speak, you'd imagine that before 1980, everyone spent all their free time sitting in circles, holding hands, and singing "Kumbaya" or the like. It's like how so many artists and thinkers get misty-eyed about the apparent pre-Industrial Revolution utopia that didn't really exist, but harder to refute because it's people's memories we're talking about here. It's pretty hard to tell someone that they remember something incorrectly.

So - were things better in the past? In the spirit of this blog, I've decided to compare things today with the women who would have read Mothercraft in the late 1940s.  Then, we shall all be enlightened! 

Things that are better now

1. Health.  My kids and I are certainly less likely to have serious health concerns than ever before, especially during that pregnancy and childbirth malarky. Plus, unlike my grandmothers, I don't have to worry about my kids getting something like polio. Awareness of mental health problems is so much better now too. The original Modern Mothercraft of 1945 doesn't say a word about post-natal depression, whereas it's well known today as something to look out for. 

2. Better ability to make your own choices. Especially for women. My grandma had to leave school at 12, whereas I was able to get a Masters Degree and forge a career. I'd like to think my daughter will have even more choices than I had. Whatever your views on contraception and abortion, there is also no denying that they've allowed women to have much more choice over what size family they have, which contributes to women having children later. I reckon boys have more choices too. If my son wants to grow up to become a ballerina or a make-up artist I'd like to think he'd be able to, at least more able to do so that had he been born in the past.

3. The World feels smaller. It's much easier to teach my children about other countries and cultures due to the Internet. Different cultures and religions are also more celebrated, meaning that in the last six months we've been able to take our toddler to both a Diwali festival and a Chinese New Year festival. I didn't even know what those things existed until I was in my late teens. I didn't even eat sushi until I was 21, and thought that all Chinese food was the sort you get at the fish and chip shop.

4. Tolerance. While far from perfect, there's no denying things are more tolerant now than in the 1940s. When Mothercraft was published in NZ, homosexuality still wouldn't be made legal for over 40 years, to use one example, whereas I'm going to attend a wedding next week with two grooms.

5. Cheaper goods. Of course not better for the sweat shop workers producing said goods, but there's no denying that things like clothes are cheaper now. As I blogged about earlier, though, the quality can leave something to be desired.

Friday, March 7, 2014

International Women's Day: a letter to my grandmothers

Dear grandmothers, great grandmothers, great great grandmothers, and all the rest of you that came before,

I never got to meet any of you. My grandmothers, you died in the decade before my birth, and the rest of you long before that. I've been thinking about you recently, while working on this blog. I've especially been thinking about you all now I have a daughter.  I think about all of the things I'd love to talk to you about. Most of all, I'd love to hear your stories. Not the big and exciting stories that make it into the history books, but the simple, everyday ones. Like: what was your favourite article of clothing when you were in your 20s? What were your labours like? How did you fix your hair? What chores did you hate the most? Was the father of your children your first love, or a love at all? What did you do for fun? Did you do anything for fun? Did you want to travel? Were you happy? 

And to the women of my matrilineal line - my mother's mother's mother's mother's right back to the seven daughters of Eve: when you spoke to your children, were you shocked by how much like your mother you sounded? I hope so. Because I often am surprised by how much like my mother I sound, and I like the idea that I might be sounding like you too, although we've never met. 

As I write this, I'm also a little ashamed. I'm ashamed that I know so few of your names. I know the names of many of my male ancestors, as these have been better passed down through the generations. So few people even care about your names. When I was pregnant with my son, many people asked if he would be named after my father, or my husbands father. When I was pregnant with my daughter, not a single person asked that about my mother or husband's mother. It didn't occur to them, and unless that changes, my descendants won't know my name either, when they may know my husband's and my son's.

Sunday, March 2, 2014

Older mothers and 30 being the new 20

Once upon a time, I was a single 20-something who considered 9am to be far too early to get up on a Saturday morning, bought clothes that were dry clean/hand wash only, and thought all babies looked the same. 5am was more likely to bedtime after a night out than the start of a day. Back then, I also used to read Cosmopolitan religiously. Once, I read in Cosmo that 30 is the new 20. Of course, I didn't believe it. Why would I? 30 was oooooold. 20 was 20. Couldn't old people do maths?

I've been thinking of this again recently because I am now well in my mid-30s so trying to tell myself I'm still young in a manner in which 20-something me would have mocked. 30 is totally the new 20, so when I hit 40 it's really only 30, 50 is 40 etc until I'm 110 and get a special letter from King George to tell me how awesome I am for living so long. Assuming we're still a monarchy of course. And yes, thinking about that is far nicer than thinking about an impending tide of grey hair and wrinkles.

Thinking about the women that would have read Mothercraft though I have evidence that Cosmo has the right idea. Here's why:

I was 31 when my son was born, and the Plunket lady told me that was bang on average for women in my Wellington suburb. My antenatal group certainly reflected that, as we were all within a couple of years of each other in age. Turns out that's still on the old side by national standards, but not by much. According to Statistics NZ, the median age for women giving birth for the first time is 28, so I wasn't too old. Woo hoo! 

Women in the 1944 had their first children so much younger, as this table shows:

FIRST BIRTHS, BY AGE OF MOTHER
Age of Mother.First Births, Proportion per Cent. at each Age-group to Total First Births.
1914.1924.1934.1944.1948.
Under 206.737.558.907.336.68
20 and under 2535.8938.1640.3941.7944.08
25 and under 3035.0132.5932.7929.5431.01
30 and under 3515.6114.6813.1014.6112.48
35 and under 405.525.333.795.364.66
40 and under 451.161.590.991.341.06
45 and over0.080.100.040.030.03
      Totals100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00
In fact, more women were between 20 and 24 than any other age group, and over 75% under 30. By 1940s standards, I am well and truly an old mother.I suspect on average we're also much older at doing other things too, like buying houses and getting married and the like. Of course we're also getting much higher education (my grandmother left school at 12) and not living through World Wars either. 

So the question remains: have we gained a decade? I'd like to think so. Among other reasons, as 40 approaches I'd much rather think of it as the new 30, rather than what it really is. I'd like to think that Cosmo had it right this time.